The profound silence was overwhelming. At the Tour Championship earlier this month, PGA Tour Commissioner Jay Monahan faced the media with remarkable reticence when questioned about the ongoing talks between the PGA Tour and Saudi-financed LIV Golf.
Monahan diplomatically stated that the matter is still in progress and there is no public update to report.
Since June 2023, both parties have been attempting to establish a connection, facing significant obstacles along the way. The question remains: is there a genuine affection between them?
Initially, Monahan firmly stated that the PGA Tour would not seek any affiliation with LIV, even going so far as to warn that any Tour member participating in their events would face suspension. True to his word, suspensions were implemented when defections occurred.
What was once an impassable wall between the two groups has evolved into a budding romance, culminating in what can be described as an engagement.
Fast forward to this week.
Meetings are currently underway in New York between the PGA Tour and LIV Golf, attracting sharp criticism. The 9/11 Justice group has voiced their strong opposition, particularly due to the proximity of these talks to the anniversary of the horrific September 11, 2001 attacks in New York, Washington D.C., and Pennsylvania.
In a statement, Brett Eagleson, President of 9/11 Justice, expressed his dismay, stating, “Tomorrow, we commemorate the 23rd anniversary of the 9/11 tragedy, yet here we are today, in New York City, down the street from Ground Zero, and the PGA Tour and Tiger Woods are negotiating with them.” Eagleson also highlighted recent reporting by CBS, confirming the involvement of the Saudi Arabian government in the 9/11 attacks, making their negotiations even more unsettling.
The Saudi government has consistently denied these allegations.
The dilemma faced by the PGA Tour and other sports organizations lies in whether it is prudent to establish business relationships with countries that have questionable human rights records. The term “sportswashing” has emerged as countries attempt to leverage sports platforms to gain legitimacy on the global stage.
Sports organizations worldwide have been willing to accept financial investments from such countries in order to maintain their financial viability.
Following the announcement of a framework agreement, the PGA Tour secured financial backing from the Strategic Sports Group (SSG) in January 2024. The SSG, a consortium of influential sports club owners, has committed $3 billion to fund the newest endeavor, with an initial investment of $1.5 billion for PGA Tour Enterprises, a newly established for-profit company. This initiative aims to provide equity to at least 200 PGA Tour members.
Patrick Cantlay, Peter Malnati, Adam Scott, Webb Simpson, Jordan Spieth, and Tiger Woods issued a joint statement expressing their unanimous support for this historic partnership, stating, “We were proud to vote in unanimous support of this historic partnership between PGA Tour Enterprises and SSG. It was incredibly important for us to create opportunities for the players of today and in the future to be more invested in their organization, both financially and strategically.”
This not only strengthens the Tour from a business perspective but also encourages players to be fully committed to delivering and enhancing the best in golf for fans. A promising future lies ahead.
The missing piece of the puzzle lies with LIV, regarding the exact nature of their relationship and the expected level of financial investment.
Initially, LIV’s spectacle centered around securing prominent players through substantial guaranteed contracts. Tournaments feature only 54 holes, with no cuts for all events and a team format that has struggled to gain a foothold among golf fans.
Although LIV did manage to secure a small television deal, overall event ratings were even lower than reruns of “I Love Lucy.”
The rejection of LIV’s competitive format has resulted in players being denied world ranking points, which play a crucial role in securing slots in prestigious events. This has become a contentious issue, especially for LIV players in their 20s who are not otherwise exempt from major championships.
LIV also finds itself isolated from the broader golf community, as major companies affiliated with the PGA Tour are reluctant to be associated with their operations. The connection to Saudi Arabia has dissuaded significant companies from making any commitments until the outcomes of the negotiations between the two parties become clearer.
Several key questions remain unanswered. What level of equity does LIV seek within PGA Tour Enterprises? Additionally, what role will Al-Rumayyan, the head of the Public Investment Fund, play in the new entity? Initial reports suggested that he would assume the position of chairman of the board.
The schedules for both the PGA Tour and LIV have already been announced for 2025. Should the marriage between the parties materialize, a major reshuffling is highly likely for the 2026 calendar, affecting which events will remain, which will be discontinued, and the overall status of each.
During the negotiations with LIV, the PGA Tour faces several distinct challenges. Significant changes have already been implemented, including reducing the number of exempt positions for the following season from 125 to 70. This same number applies to players eligible for the first round of the FedEx Cup Playoffs.
Another pressing issue is the decline in television ratings for PGA Tour events. The departure of star players, such as Tiger Woods and Phil Mickelson, from their competitive prime has prompted serious consideration of how to generate greater viewer interest through a diverse range of events.
A potential partnership between the PGA Tour and LIV is not simply a love match; rather, it is a business alliance designed to infuse much-needed capital into the PGA Tour while establishing a new entity that seeks a broader role in golf and sports overall.
When separate entities consider joining forces, there is always uncertainty and contemplation of the long-lasting implications. The outcome of these negotiations will determine whether this union signifies a new beginning teeming with promise or ends before reaching the altar.
The balance of power now rests with PGA Tour players who sit on the policy board. Tiger Woods’ active involvement serves as a testament to the significance of these negotiations.
As couples walk down the aisle, there is an anticipation of what lies ahead, a shared belief that being together is better than remaining alone. Since June 2022, professional golf has been divided, with many top players, including Rory McIlroy, emphasizing the necessity of having all key players regularly competing against each other.
Make no mistake—the wedding vow of “till death do us part” is no exaggeration in this case. The outcome of these negotiations will determine whether this marriage represents a new promising chapter or fizzles out before vows are exchanged and the altar is approached.
Discover more from Tension News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.